People Photo Place

In 1967, a French philosopher named Guy Debord published ‘The Society of the Spectacle’, a seminal text critiquing contemporary consumer culture, mass media and the pacification of people’s minds through the bombardment of imagery- which he terms as the ‘Spectacle’. He writes, ’In societies where modern conditions of production prevail, all of life presents itself as an immense accumulation of spectacles. Everything that was directly lived has moved away into a representation.’ 


Today, architectural practices and its allied fields seem to have reached that point where the image has superseded the lived. Here, ‘What appears is good; what is good appears.’ The emergence of numerous digital magazines operating in tandem with social media algorithms have only accelerated this phenomenon. Where the medium one works through, drastically alters the way we respond to, write about and manifest design thinking. Agreed that platforms like Instagram, Pinterest etc. give a sense of agency, autonomy, direct engagement with potential clients and a larger viewership to magazines and design practices, but at what cost? Architectural practice is being reduced down to a ‘trend culture’ where the aesthetic sells to a point where everything begins to look the same. So much for standardization in a free market economy. 


‘The framework that we have made for ourselves of creating a world of images has so disconnected us from flesh and blood realities, that it has forgotten that we have bodies.’ says Neelkanth Chhaya in his talk ‘Get Real Now’ at KRVIA. He goes on to critique the deliberate disconnect that the profession has created between the people and the place, where ‘the lived’ is being side tracked. Architecture today is a frozen image, an absolute perfect assemblage of things that propagate instantaneous image making. As a result, architectural writing becomes the descriptive footnotes that accompany the image. Growing number of courses regarding ‘brand building, content marketing, aesthetic styling, shooting + publication packages’ on  social media are a testimony to this culture. A deeper problem is the impact that global economic forces and media pacification are having on the minds of creative professionals today. Killing intuitive thought processes, the want for experimentation, the ability to take risks- even fail and are rather settling for ‘what is known to sell/work.’ Prioritising instant gratification over sustained growth. People are inclined towards designing with a final image in mind instead of the experience that architecture creates. 


Chhaya questions, ‘Is our profession then doomed to be the creator of marvelous illusions that seduce humanity away from what is, and perpetuate the operation of a system of endless consumption and distraction?’ A simple google search for a topic will provide  articles by innumerous magazines that give identical answers. Where, say the list of ‘The Top 10 Sustainable Practices in India’ or ‘5 books that every architect must read’ for virtually every magazine is the same, often in the exact same sequence too. This is a result of mindless replication. From magazines to digital articles to Instagram posts and now even to reels. ‘Content’ is created with google search tags in mind, posts designed for maximum readership- hugely tarnishing the collective memory and knowledge systems of our community at this point in time. 


Chhaya goes on to urge, ‘The profession must find in itself the courage not to collaborate with the ongoing processes of brainwashing minds into the marketplace of trendy media cultures. This is difficult in an era of technomangerial control, market and media driven economies.’ However, to retain the meaning of what we do, the profession needs to find ways to redefine ourselves. How we design, critique and assess our work within the built environment. In his words, ‘Architects will have to connect more directly with people, places and practices. They will have to find ingenious ways of attending to real conditions. This might need and might allow alternate terms of framing knowledge, distinct from professional jargons and the fashions in the magazines. Professional world ideally has to become a repository, a seed bank, a petri dish that preserves, protects, extends, questions and generally keeps alive that messy and unmanageable diversity of knowledge and practices in the face of the entropic nuclear winter of a universalized monoculture of minds.’ It is time to break away from the Spectacle and pursue the truth, whatever it may be. 


 







Comments

Popular posts from this blog

On Practice/ Interviews of Architecture Graduates